Pie Guy's Pizzeria Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Pie Guy's Pizzeria, an enchanting culinary gem located at 94 Picton Main St, Picton, Ontario. This delightful eatery is celebrated not just for its incredible pizzas but also for its welcoming atmosphere and exceptional service. Customers rave about the quality of ingredients and the generosity of toppings that adorn each pizza, creating flavors that leave a lasting impression.
- Signature Pizzas: Expect a menu that dazzles with creative combinations and expertly crafted crusts, providing the perfect balance of chewiness and flavor.
- Wings & More: As renowned as the pizzas are the homemade wings, complemented by flavorful sauces that keep patrons coming back for more.
- Gourmet Touch: Locals and visitors alike agree that Pie Guy’s rivals even the top eateries in larger cities, making it a must-visit while in Prince Edward County.
With late-night delivery until 2 a.m., indulge in your cravings at any hour—Pie Guy’s Pizzeria is truly a slice of heaven!
Pizza
10" Regular or Gluten Free(5.00 more) Pizza
Toppings: Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Smoked Bacon, Ham, Spiced Ground Beef, Roasted or Jerk Chicken, Anchovies, Red Onion, Mushrooms, Sweet Peppers, Hot Peppers, Black or Green Olives, Pineapple, Feta, Spinach, Basil, Garlic and Tomatoes 1 Topping - 15.75 2 Topping - 16.75 3 Topping - 17.75 4 Topping - 18.75 5 Topping - 19.75 Additional Toppings - 1.75 Extra Cheese - 2.75 Special Sauce Bases (Butter Chicken Sauce, Chili Sauce, Olive Oil and Herbs) - 2.75
14" Pizza
Toppings: Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Smoked Bacon, Ham, Spiced Ground Beef, Roasted or Jerk Chicken, Anchovies, Red Onion, Mushrooms, Sweet Peppers, Hot Peppers, Black or Green Olives, Pineapple, Feta, Spinach, Basil, Garlic and Tomatoes 1 Topping - 25.75 2 Topping - 26.75 3 Topping - 28.75 4 Topping - 29.75 5 Topping - 30.75 Additional Toppings - 2.75 Extra Cheese - 3.75 Special Sauce Bases (Butter Chicken Sauce, Chili Sauce, Olive Oil and Herbs) - 3.75
16" Pizza
Toppings: Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Smoked Bacon, Ham, Spiced Ground Beef, Roasted or Jerk Chicken, Anchovies, Red Onion, Mushrooms, Sweet Peppers, Hot Peppers, Black or Green Olives, Pineapple, Feta, Spinach, Basil, Garlic and Tomatoes 1 Topping - 27.75 2 Topping - 29.75 3 Topping - 30.75 4 Topping - 31.75 5 Topping - 32.75 Additional Toppings - 3.75 Extra Cheese - 5.75 Special Sauce Bases (Butter Chicken Sauce, Chili Sauce, Olive Oil and Herbs) - 4.75
Traditional
Available in Tourtiere, Beef Vegetable, Chicken Vegetable, and Cottage Pie. All pies are pre-cooked and can be ordered hot and ready or frozen to save for later!
Specialty
Available in Seafood, Sirloin Beef, Mushroom and Red Wine, Butter Chicken, Butter Veg, Ground Lamb, and Shepherd's Pie. All pies are pre-cooked and can be ordered hot and ready or frozen to save for later!
Homemade 5-inch Meat pies
Mains
Full Rack of Ribs
Perfectly smoked and covered in BBQ sauce. Add fries and coleslaw for 4.80.
Half Rack of Ribs
Perfectly smoked and covered in BBQ sauce. Add fries and coleslaw for 4.80.
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Jerk Chicken - Full Bird
Add fries and coleslaw for 4.80.
Jerk Chicken - Half Bird
Add fries and coleslaw for 4.80.
1.5 lb. Jumbo Chicken Wings
Served with veggie sticks and our Blue Cheese Garlic Dip. Available in Dry Cajun, Dry Garlic, Sweet Chili Heat, Honey Garlic, Lemon Pepper, Italian Herbs, Parmesan Cheese, Jamaican Jerk, and Buffalo (Mild to Kick Ass Hot)!
Boneless Chicken Thighs
Served with veggie sticks and our Blue Cheese Garlic Dip. Available in Dry Cajun, Dry Garlic, Sweet Chili Heat, Honey Garlic, Lemon Pepper, Italian Herbs, Parmesan Cheese, Jamaican Jerk, and Buffalo (Mild to Kick Ass Hot)!
Boneless Chicken Breast Fingers
Served with fries. Available in Dry Cajun, Dry Garlic, Sweet Chili Heat, Honey Garlic, Lemon Pepper, Italian Herbs, Parmesan Cheese, Jamaican Jerk, and Buffalo (Mild to Kick Ass Hot)!
Meatball Sandwich with Melted Cheese
All Beef 8oz Burger
A build-your-own burger with all the standard fixings available. Add bacon, cheese or mushrooms for 2.50!
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Onion Rings
Small Fry
Large Fry
Small Poutine
Large Poutine
Small Caesar Salad
Large Caesar Salad
Small Greek Salad
Large Greek Salad
Sides
Drinks
Canned Pop
Dipping Sauce
Spicy Aioli, Garlic, Ranch, and Blue Cheese